Printable Version in PDF Format (Get Adobe Acrobat)
The existing CSUCI Time, Place Manner policy will continue to apply to union-represented employees until the unions have completed bargaining. The Systemwide Time, Place, Manner policy will apply to all employees following the conclusion of the bargaining.
However, the Systemwide Time, Place, Manner policy will apply to all CSU students and non-affiliates.
History
- Policy Number: OP.01.008
- Version:
- Drafted By:
- Approved By: Erika D. Beck
- Approval Date:
- Effective Date: 09/17/2018
- Supersedes:
Purpose
To ensure that various forms of freedom of expression are encouraged and supported for members of the campus community and public with respect to time, place, and manner limitations, with regard to the appropriate use of University buildings and grounds.
Background
Freedom of expression is a cornerstone of a democratic society and is essential to
the educational process. The academic mission of the campuses within the California
State University system necessitates the free exchange of ideas and vigorous debate
of ideas and information. That includes the freedom to draw connections between controversial
issues and the subject matter at hand. Controversy is at the heart of free academic
inquiry. Therefore, discussing controversial content on campus does not in and of
itself violate University policies nor will the discussion itself serve as a basis
for limiting future expression, even if a campus community member feels uncomfortable
with the content or finds the content to be offensive.
CSUCI encourages and supports the free expression of ideas, values and opinions, recognizing
that such expression may take a variety of forms, such as speeches, signs, written
materials, public assemblies, parades, demonstrations, artistic representation and
other forms of expressive conduct. While one may find certain expressions or materials
to be offensive or insulting, the appropriate way to counteract such materials is
through discourse, constructive criticism, and the expression of additional points
of view.
At the same time, all members of the University community should recognize that freedom
of expression includes a responsibility to respect the rights of others, including
the right to express differing opinions. There shall be no restrictions on legal free
speech activity based on the content of such speech or expression or on the political,
religious or other opinions and affiliations of speakers. Correspondingly, the exercise
of free speech, including opposing the speech or viewpoints of others, and assembly
rights must comply with all federal, state and local laws.
This policy is promulgated under the authority of Title 5 of the California Code of
Regulations, Sections 42350-42353, subsequent directives, resolutions, standing orders,
and Executive Orders of the Board of Trustees and Chancellor of the California State
University and the President of CSUCI.
Policy
Accountability
Office of the President, Provost, Vice President for Business & Financial Affairs, Vice President for Student Affairs, and Vice President for University Advancement.
Applicability
All CSUCI students, faculty, employees, auxiliaries, tenants, and visitors to the
campus.
Nothing in this policy shall interfere with the statutory right provided by the Higher
Education Employer-Employee Relations Act, California Government Code Section 3560,
et. seq., or the terms of a controlling Collective Bargaining Agreement. Nothing in
this policy shall prohibit the unions from communicating with its members regarding
union-related activities or engaging in protected or concerted activities.
Definition(s)
Amplified Sound: any sound that is broadcast through electronically amplified equipment
or sound that is electronically enhanced. Hand-held amplification, e.g. bullhorns,
megaphones, etc. are considered sound amplification devices under this policy.
Commercial Solicitation: means any direct and personal communication in the course
of a trade or business reasonably intended to result in a sale.
Commercial Transaction: selling or purchasing or both selling and purchasing by any
person in the course of employment in, or in the carrying on of, a trade or business.
Handbills/Circulars: a printed advertisement or other notice distributed by hand and/or
intended for wide distribution. Handbills do not include bumper stickers, sun shades
or other decals/ornaments/signs on an individual’s personal vehicle.
Manner: manner-based limitations are those which regulate the mode of individual expression.
Place: place-based limitations are those which regulate where individuals may express
themselves.
Private sales: means occasional selling between persons who are campus students or
employees.
Sale: “selling” or “purchasing” means an activity creating an obligation to transfer
property or services for a valuable consideration.
Solicitation: means to importune, or endeavor to persuade or obtain by asking, but
does not include “commercial solicitation.”
Time: time-based limitations are those which regulate when individuals may express
themselves.
Text
- Time, Place and Manner Regulations CSUCI may establish reasonable time, place, and
manner regulations regarding the use of its public facilities to ensure that individuals
and groups exercising their legitimate rights do not infringe on the rights of others
or disrupt the educational process or other operations of the University.
The exercise of free speech and assembly rights must comply with all applicable federal, state and local law. In addition, the following “manner” restrictions apply to all free speech and assembly activities on campus. Such activities must not:- unduly interfere with classes in session or other scheduled academic, educational, cultural/arts programs, or with use of the University library; unreasonably obstruct the flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic or circulation;
- unduly interfere with or disrupt the conduct of University business;
- employ unauthorized sound amplification or create unreasonable noise disruptive of normal University activities;
- severely harass or intimidate persons in the immediate area of the activity; or
- violate any federal, state or local safety code, such as regulations set by the State Fire Marshal.
There shall be no restrictions on legal free speech activity based on the content
of such speech or expression or on the political, religious, or other opinions and
affiliations of speakers. Speech that is otherwise protected may not be disallowed
solely because it is offensive, or because members of the audience find it offensive,
even where such members react to the speech in a disruptive manner. To disallow speech
on such grounds would violate a First Amendment ban otherwise known as the “heckler’s
veto.”
When speech is part of a planned speaker (e.g. an invited speaker), an individual
or group wishing to protest an event may do so as long as any speaker’s right to free
speech and the audience’s right to see and to hear a speaker are not violated.
In the interest of protecting the free speech rights of all, University representatives
may warn anyone unduly interfering with a speaker’s freedom of expression, the right
of others to see and hear such speaker, and the right to peaceably assemble, to cease
the disruptive behavior. If such warnings are not heeded, those individuals may be
removed from the facility or area.
Conduct that physically endangers the safety of both active and passive bystanders
is not permissible. The University reserves the right to cancel or postpone an event
if there is a reasonable concern for safety of persons or for University property.
B. Use of Buildings, Facilities or Grounds The University permits individuals and
groups to use certain University buildings and grounds for activities other than scheduled
instruction. The University gives its highest priority to the facilitation of scheduled
instruction.
The second priority is the scheduling of activities and events that directly support
the instructional mission, such as: scholarly and creative activities organized by
faculty, staff and students; visual and performing arts; co-curricular programs; intercollegiate
or recreational meets and activities; public programs offered by Extended University;
administrative activities, camps and conferences; grant and contract activities; and
student recruitment and yield-enhancing events and programs.
The third scheduling priority is hosting activities and events that may not support
the institutional mission. Events that fall under this category can include, but are
not limited to sporting events, special occasions and meetings.
C. Preferred Public Forum Spaces CSUCI’s Central Mall between University and Ojai
Halls, as well as the John Spoor Broome Library Plaza, are preferred public forum
spaces in which members of the University community and non University community may
exercise their free speech rights without special restriction, subject only to the
general limitations noted in Section A, unless sound amplification is to be used,
in which case prior permission must be requested as described in Section E.
Free-speech activities may be exercised in other outdoor areas (other than turf athletic/recreational
fields), subject to the other provisions of this policy. These areas are available
to individual students, faculty and staff and to University organizations on a first-come,
first-served basis for free speech activities, unless sound amplification is to be
used in which case prior approval must be granted as described in Section E.
D. Public Meetings, Performances, Rallies, Demonstrations or Similar Events Members
of the University community and non-University community may use University buildings
and grounds for public meetings, conferences, performances, rallies, demonstrations,
and similar events.
Non-amplified outdoor demonstrations or public protests may be held on University
property, without advance permission, provided they adhere to the limitations described
in this policy.
Demonstrations, rallies and other public events may not unduly disrupt the business
of the University or its educational mission. For example, they may not be conducted
in or within the immediate vicinity of classrooms, offices, residence halls, athletic/recreational
fields or facilities, or reception areas, so as to disrupt the operations and users
of those facilities.
While on CSUCI property, participants or attendees at a public meeting, performance,
rally, demonstration, or similar event are prohibited from the following immediately
before, during, or immediately after the event to maintain public safety:
- Possessing any weapons or tools that can be used as weapons, including bats, clubs, shields, armor, flammable objects, or sticks excluding those attached to a sign or poster;
- Wearing a helmet or armor; and
- Possessing any other item prohibited by University policy or law.
Speakers at such meetings, performances, rallies, demonstrations or similar events
shall not be subject to harassment, nor shall the right of all to hear the speaker
be infringed. At the same time, members of the campus community and external guests
shall have the right to peacefully protest any speaker, meeting or event.
Spontaneous events occasioned by news coming into public knowledge less than 48 hours
prior to such event may be held at the preferred public forum spaces identified in
Section C, as well as outdoors (other than turf athletic/recreational fields) without
advance permission.
Camping on University property or living in temporary lodging parked or erected on
University property is prohibited, except where such camping or temporary lodging
is specifically authorized by the University.
The University reserves the right to limit, re-direct, or provide appropriate barriers
to pedestrian and/or vehicular traffic before, during, or after an event to protect
the health, safety, and security of persons or property.
E. Sound Amplification The following guidelines are established for the use of amplified
sound equipment when classes are in session to protect the delivery of instructional
programs from intrusive sound and yet still provide an opportunity and a forum for
a variety of student development and support programs. An appropriate balance of these
two goals may be achieved by observing the conditions noted below.
- Outdoor sound amplification is limited to the Central Mall between University and Ojai Halls, except where advance approval is obtained from Conferences & Events with decisions for approval provided without unreasonable delay.
- Amplified sound is intended to be heard in the immediate area only and is subject to monitoring and regulation.
- The sound level for any event, including non-amplified sound such as drumming, may not exceed that which is disruptive to the instructional programs, scheduled events, and/or library or classroom study.
Approval for amplification at special times and places shall not be granted or denied
on the basis of the content or viewpoint of the activity.
F. Solicitation (Commercial Transactions and Non-Commercial Solicitation) In accordance
with Section 42350 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, commercial transactions
and the display of property or services for sale on the University’s campus is prohibited
except with advance written approval. Generally, private sales are excluded unless
otherwise noted.
Such permission shall be granted if the proposed activity:
- aids achievement of the educational mission and/or student development objectives of the campus;
- conforms to the time, place and manner and general limitations described in Section A;
- has published materials for sale that are not available for sale at the campus bookstore;
- does not unreasonably interfere with the operation of the campus; and
- is not prohibited by law.
The sale, solicitation, and/or display of goods and services, including private sales,
that violate federal or state law, e.g. illegal drugs and/or drug paraphernalia, weapons,
illegal gambling, free merchandise or giveaways, etc., or that are prohibited by the
University, shall not be permitted. The sale of food items is prohibited unless advance
approval is obtained from the University’s Auxiliary Services.
Any published materials offered for sale, including private sales, or for free, must
not violate the provisions of Chapter 7.5, Title 9, Part 1 of the Penal Code (relating
to the sale and distribution of obscene matter) or Chapter 6, Title 3 (commencing
with Section 66400) of the Education Code (relating to the preparation, sale and distribution
of term papers, theses, and other materials to be submitted for academic credit).
Non-commercial solicitations such as ballot signature-gathering, information provided
by non-profit organizations, or other non-commercial solicitations, are allowed with
a preference for them to occur at the preferred public forum spaces as outlined in
Section C.
Soliciting alms or begging in public places or in any place open to the public on
University property is allowed within the limitations provided under California Penal
Code Section 647(c).
G. Handbills/Circulars Non-commercial handbills and circulars may be distributed by
hand at the preferred public forum spaces identified in Section C as well as other
University walkways and outside entrances to University buildings provided that the
activity conforms to the general limitations described in Sections A and H.
Individuals or groups distributing materials in these areas, other than materials
discarded or dropped into appropriate receptacles, shall make a reasonable effort
to retrieve and remove such materials prior to their departure from the campus. Handbills
and circulars should not be left behind in any areas or placed within any other CSUCI
materials.
Handbills and circulars may not be posted on outdoor surfaces such as buildings, structures,
poles, trees, benches, balconies, railings, windows, objects, vehicle windows, or
campus bulletin boards.
H. Display or Distribution of Published Materials The display and free distribution
of books, newspapers, pamphlets, and other published materials are permitted, provided
that such published materials are not available for sale at the University’s bookstore,
and that they do not violate the provisions of Chapter 7.5, Title 9, Part 1 of the
Penal Code (relating to the sale and distribution of obscene matter) or Chapter 6,
Title 3 (commencing with Section 66400) of the Education Code (relating to the preparation,
sale, and distribution of term papers, theses, and other materials to be submitted
for academic credit).
The display and distribution of published materials are permitted provided such activity
conforms to the general limitations in Section A and there is:
- no harassment of persons in the area;
- no physical contact of individuals without their consent;
- no prolonged or repeated contact with persons who have declined the material, except to the extent that such contact is protected by the Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act (see Applicability section);
- no sound amplification, refer to Section E;
- no illegal misrepresentation of the true name and purpose of the material or of any organization involved in its distribution;
- materials must contain a contact name, telephone number or email address.
I. Postings The University recognizes that materials including fliers, posters, banners,
lawn signs or flags, chalking, notices, etc., serve as a means for communicating information
to the campus community in a timely and orderly manner. The University reserves the
sole right to post signage for emergency and safety purposes on otherwise prohibited
surfaces and locations.
All postings must be approved in advance as follows:
- CSU union-affiliated activities and communication: no approval necessary
- CSUCI academically-related postings by faculty and staff: no approval necessary
- Students or Student Clubs and Organizations: approved by Campus Life
- Staff (non-academically-related): approved by their respective Vice President (or designee)
- External individuals, businesses, non-profits or organizations: approved by Communication & Marketing
Requests for lawn banners/flags; lawn signs; display boards (‘A’ frames); temporary
outdoor displays, exhibits or message boards; or postings using water-soluble chalk,
shall be reviewed and approved in advance as noted above and are only allowed for
University-related events and activities or academically-related, and within the designated
spaces and parameters identified within the Policy’s corresponding procedure.
Authorized or approved materials may not be removed, defaced or covered to make room
for additional materials or for any other reason except by appropriate University
staff. Postings are prohibited from the following: acoustic boards, building walls/lobbies,
balconies, benches, bridges, bus shelters, doors, fences, fountains/sculptures, light
posts, newspaper or magazine racks, permanent way-finding signage, railings, restrooms/stalls,
stairwells, traffic mirrors or control signs, trees, trash or recycling receptacles,
and windows.
Divisions, programs, or areas may display posters, photographs, awards, or artwork
within their designated office space.
Faculty and staff may post materials on their own office doors, windows or bulletin
boards.
Damage caused by inappropriate or prohibited postings on office doors, windows or
walls by any program, area, individual, or organization, for which they are responsible,
may be charged for the cost incurred in the removal or repair of University facilities.
Postings for Non-commercial or Commercial Solicitations/Transactions Requests for posting of non-commercial or commercial solicitations/transactions require
advance approval as noted above. Non-University affiliated individuals or groups may
have their posting privileges revoked under Section 626 et. seq. of the California
Penal Code.
Exhibit(s)
Procedure for Time, Place and Manner and the Use of University Buildings and Grounds